The Business Ombudsman Council provides recommendations to state bodies on the basis of individual cases and in accordance with published systemic reports. Here we have collected information on the implementation status of systemic recommendations only.

To amend internal regulations and to take appropriate organizational steps in order to indicate a responsible department with functions of:  

(1) monitoring court decisions to be executed,  

(2) monitoring the process of such decisions execution and  

(3) preparation of regular public reports on the implementation, as well as on problematic issues creating obstacles to proper court decisions execution.

State Tax Service of Ukraine
State Customs Service

To adjust the administrative practice, when applying certain legislation, with regard to the case-law on similar issues. This should provide not only for formal monitoring, but also for a real change in the law application practice of a state body. In particular, to amend the regulations related to the administrative appeal procedure and to oblige the authorities to add a brief overview of the relevant court practice in the text of each decision made as a result of the administrative appeal procedure and/or to make the decision in line with the court practice or to provide relevant reasoning for deviations from it. The criterion for changing law application practice may be a significant change in the results of court proceedings (up to the rate of decision-making to satisfy the claim of business entities to the state body no more than 40% in the respective categories of cases) or a significant reduction in the total number of lawsuits (mutatis mutandis/in other conditions being equal).

State Tax Service of Ukraine
State Customs Service