66954

10.09.2024

From Procedural Violations to Positive Changes: The Story of a Fuel Distributor

Bureau of Economic Security (BEB) Kyiv

A company with foreign investments, a fuel distributor in Ukraine, faced significant challenges within a criminal investigation. During the lengthy pre-trial investigation initiated by the Bureau of Economic Security (BEB) against the company, it encountered several procedural violations by the pre-trial investigation body. In particular, BEB detectives failed for months to comply with nearly a dozen investigative judge rulings, that required them to reconsider the company’s petition for conducting investigative and procedural actions.

Due to this situation, the company decided to seek assistance of the Business Ombudsman Council (BOC). BOC sent an official letter to the Prosecutor General’s Office and BEB, drawing their attention to the fact that BEB detectives had not responded promptly to the company’s requests.

The BOC’s intervention yielded swift results. Within a few days after the Council’s involvement, the company’s lawyers received several responses in the form of letters and rulings following the review of previously submitted applications. Although not all responses fully satisfied the company, the improvement in communication was seen as significant progress.

Moreover, the BOC’s attention to the case led to significant changes in the investigation process. Two months after the Council’s intervention, a senior BEB detective closed one of the criminal case episodes due to the absence of criminal elements in the actions of the company’s management.

Representatives of the company noted that the Business Ombudsman Council’s assistance contributed to improved communication with BEB, accelerated the consideration of their applications, which ultimately led to positive changes in the pre-trial investigation of criminal proceedings.

Next case:: Tax Obstacles After a Court Victory: The Path to VAT Reinstatement